Two-sided marketplace design: how to design for buyers and sellers
How to design a two-sided marketplace: a front door for the paying side, separate onboarding, the first transaction, trust signals and one shared design system.

Two-sided marketplace design means building two products that share one database: one for the side that pays and one for the side that supplies. Start with a public front door that leads with your main buyer, give each side its own onboarding and dashboard, design the first transaction end to end, and build one design system both sides share.
Why marketplace design is harder than regular SaaS design
A normal SaaS product has one main user with one main goal. A marketplace has at least two, and their goals pull in different directions. Buyers want choice, speed, and proof that the other side is real. Suppliers want demand, fair terms, and to get paid without chasing anyone.
One founder on r/EntrepreneurRideAlong summed up the problem after building a creator marketplace: retention on a marketplace is really two separate products with two separate reasons to leave. Suppliers leave when their applications go nowhere. Buyers leave when the second transaction takes as much effort as the first.
That is a design problem as much as a growth problem. Every screen has to answer two questions: which side is looking at it, and what do they need to trust before they act.
Design the front door for the side that pays
The first decision is who your homepage speaks to. A common answer on r/userexperience is that the public front door of most marketplaces is built around the demand side, because they are the source of revenue and usually far outnumber suppliers. The supply side gets a clear link in the header and its own landing page.
Some founders try a split homepage with two big buttons, "I'm a buyer" and "I'm a seller." That can work while you are validating the idea and collecting waitlist signups for both sides. Once you have traffic, it adds a step for the people you most need to convert. A better default:
- Lead the homepage with the buyer's outcome and real examples of supply.
- Put a "For creators" or "For sellers" link in the main navigation.
- Give the supply side its own page with earnings, how payment works, and what is expected of them.
- Check your analytics after a month and let the data tell you if the balance is wrong.
If your website and product are being designed separately, this is where the two need to agree. The promise on the landing page has to match the first screen after signup, for both sides.
Two onboarding flows, not one with a toggle
Onboarding is where most marketplace products quietly lose people. A single form with a role switch at the top usually ends up asking both sides for information only one of them needs.
Supply side onboarding
Suppliers need to understand three things before they finish setting up:
- What kind of work or listings perform well here.
- How and when they get paid.
- What happens after they apply, list, or submit.
The third point matters most. If a creator applies to a campaign and hears nothing, they assume the platform is empty. Design status states for every step: submitted, under review, accepted, in progress, paid. An empty dashboard should explain what to do next, not just show a blank table.
Demand side onboarding
Buyers need to get to their first result quickly. Ask for the minimum to post a request, launch a campaign, or book a provider, and collect the rest later. Show them real supply as early as possible, even before they finish setup, because seeing actual profiles or listings is what makes the marketplace feel alive.
Design the first transaction from both sides
Most marketplace teams design screens. The better approach is to design one full transaction, from both sides, before polishing anything else.
Take a brand and creator marketplace as an example. The full loop looks like this:
- The brand creates a campaign and sets terms.
- Creators discover it, check the terms, and apply.
- The brand reviews applications and accepts some.
- Creators produce and submit content.
- The brand approves or asks for changes.
- Creators get paid, and both sides see the result.
Lay these steps out side by side and you find the gaps fast. Who gets notified at each step? What does each side see while they wait? Where does money show up, and when? Any step where one side is left guessing is a step where people drop out.
Trust and money are part of the interface
When real money moves between strangers, visual polish stops being a nice extra. People decide in seconds whether a platform looks safe enough to connect a payment method or invest hours of work.
The elements that carry most of that trust:
- Clear payment status. Pending, approved, and paid should look different and be easy to find.
- Profiles with proof. Past work, ratings, or completed jobs, shown the same way on every profile.
- Plain terms. Fees, payout timing, and revision rules stated on the screen where the decision happens, not only in a help article.
- Consistent interface. Mismatched buttons and layouts make a platform look unfinished, and unfinished platforms feel risky.
That last point is easy to underrate. A developer-built interface can work perfectly and still lose users because it does not look like something you would trust with money.
What we learned redesigning a creator marketplace
We saw all of this firsthand on Methods, a UGC marketplace built by instinct© that connects brands with content creators. Brands launch campaigns, creators apply, produce short-form videos, and get paid based on performance.
When we started, Methods had a functional product with a developer-built interface and no design system behind it. Some workflows needed extra steps for simple inputs, and the information architecture made it hard to tell what belonged where. For a platform handling thousands of creators and real money, the design was behind the product's ambition.
The work ran in three phases:
- A one-week sprint to set the visual foundation: core screens, layout patterns, and direction.
- A second sprint delivering around 30 screens with light and dark themes and a full component system covering every state.
- A monthly retainer, where the founders rethought the product around an AI chat interface and workflow automations. We designed around 30 more screens and rebuilt the design system underneath, while coordinating directly with their development team.
In total that was more than 60 screens across two product directions. Methods kept growing during and after the engagement, scaling past 10,000 creators and paying out more than $1 million through the platform. Many things drove that growth. What the design work gave them was a product that looked credible enough for both sides to trust it with campaigns and payouts.
The lesson we took from it: a marketplace rarely needs one big redesign. It needs a solid foundation first, then a partner who can keep designing as the product changes direction. If you are at that point with your own marketplace, we are happy to look at your product and tell you where we would start.
Build one design system for both sides
It is tempting to treat the buyer app and the supplier app as separate projects. Resist that. Both sides should share one component library: the same buttons, cards, status badges, forms, and type styles. The layouts and priorities differ, but the building blocks should not.
A shared system pays off in a few ways:
- Developers build new features faster because both sides reuse the same parts.
- A status badge means the same thing to a buyer and a supplier, which cuts support questions.
- When you add a third role, such as an admin or an agency managing several accounts, you are not starting over.
If you are unsure whether you are ready for this, our guide on when a startup needs a design system covers the signals. For marketplaces, the answer usually comes sooner than for single-user SaaS, because you are maintaining two products from day one.
Prototype both sides before you build
Marketplaces are expensive to get wrong in code, because every change touches two sets of screens. A clickable prototype of both flows lets you test the full loop with a few real buyers and suppliers before engineering commits.
We used this approach on Zenspun, an internal concept for a Gen Z therapy app. In a three-day sprint we mapped and designed the full product flow, including onboarding, freemium and premium paths, a feed, and a psychologist marketplace, then turned it into an interactive prototype. It was not a client project, but it shows how much of a two-sided product you can test before writing production code.
For more on how much to design before building, see how much design an MVP needs.
Sprint or ongoing support?
A focused sprint works well when you need a clear foundation: core flows for both sides, a design system, and a prototype. Ongoing support makes more sense once you are live and shipping changes every week, because marketplaces keep changing as you learn which side needs more help.
On our plans, a Retainer at $5,000 per month covers one request at a time, with updates every other business day. Retainer Plus at $9,000 per month covers two requests at once, each updated every other business day, which suits teams working on the buyer and supplier sides in parallel. Custom projects start from $2,000. Our comparison of design retainers vs one-off projects goes deeper on which fits.
Common marketplace design mistakes
- Designing only the side you understand best. Founders often come from one side of the market and underdesign the other.
- Empty states that look broken. A blank list with no guidance reads as a dead platform.
- Hiding fees until checkout. Surprises around money cost more trust than almost anything else.
- No status after an action. Every application, order, or submission needs a visible next step.
- Separate design languages per side. It doubles the work and makes the product feel like two companies.
Getting started
Before you redesign anything, write down the full transaction for both sides and mark every point where someone waits, pays, or has to trust a stranger. Those are the screens that matter most.
If you are building or redesigning a marketplace and want a team that has worked through these problems on a live product, get in touch with us. We will look at both sides of your product and tell you honestly where design can help most.
Related articles
- Oct 27, 2026Developer tool website design: what developers look for before they sign upDeveloper tool website design that converts: lead with the problem, show real code, put docs and pricing up front, and add the trust signals developers check.
- Sep 27, 2026SaaS pricing page design: the mistakes that make buyers hesitateA SaaS pricing page fails on clarity long before it fails on price. Here are the mistakes that make buyers hesitate, and what actually earns the click.
- Sep 21, 2026Fintech app design: how startups earn user trust before they have a nameEarly-stage fintech startups have no brand history to lean on. Here is how product design signals trust before users have any other reason to believe you.

Hey, I'm Razvan, founder of
Artone Studio.
I’ve spent the last 9+ years helping startups, from zero to funded, turn ideas into products investors notice and users love.
At Artone, we design with purpose. We care about how things look, but even more about how they work. If you’re building something ambitious and want a design partner who gets it, let’s talk.